The Supreme Court won’t hear the challenge to Maryland’s long list of gun-free zones. But don’t read that as the end of the fight.
On Monday, November 16, 2026, the Court denied cert in Novotny v. Moore, the case challenging Maryland’s ban on carrying in a long list of so-called “sensitive places.” That leaves the Fourth Circuit’s decision upholding most of those restrictions in place.
The more interesting part came alongside the denial. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote a statement explaining why he agreed with turning the case away, and in doing so, he laid out the kind of sensitive places case the Court may want to hear.

What Maryland Bans
Under Maryland law, a permit holder can’t carry at public demonstrations, on mass transit, at places of amusement, in healthcare facilities, at places that serve alcohol for on-site consumption, or on tens of thousands of acres of state park and forest land. The whole thing is trash law designed to make it so you can’t really carry anywhere.
The Fourth Circuit upheld nearly all of it in Kipke v. Moore, reasoning that each location qualified as a sensitive place. Novotny asked the Supreme Court to review that decision.
Why Thomas Agreed to Deny the Case
Thomas made it clear he’s not a fan of Maryland’s list. He wrote that he is skeptical each of these laws fits the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.
So why agree with the denial? Because the challenge was too broad. Each Maryland restriction rests on its own historical argument. Bars aren’t parks, and parks aren’t hospitals. Reviewing all of them in one case would make it harder for the Court to set a clear rule.
His bottom line: in a more narrowly focused case, the Court should take up how far states can go in declaring places off-limits.
“Sensitive Places” Was Supposed to Be Narrow
This is the part I’m paying attention to.
When the Court decided Bruen in 2022, it acknowledged that some places have historically been off-limits to guns: legislative assemblies, polling places, and courthouses. It also said the historical record shows relatively few of those places.
Thomas pointed to what several states did after Bruen. New Jersey listed about 25 locations. New York listed 20. California listed 29. Zoos, libraries, beaches, parks, casinos, athletic facilities, public gatherings. Put together, these lists cover just about everywhere people eat, drink, recreate, or speak and since the laws also say things like “within 100 feet of” these locations it basically removes free movement anywhere with a gun.
Thomas warned that treating every place people gather as “sensitive” would gut the general right to carry in public for self-defense. That’s exactly what Bruen said states can’t do.
What a Narrower Case Could Look Like
The Court may not have to wait long for one.
Christian v. James, a challenge to New York’s ban on carrying in public parks, is already on the Court’s docket (No. 26-374). It asks about a single type of place. That’s the kind of focused case Thomas described.
There’s also New Jersey. Thomas noted that the Third Circuit is rehearing New Jersey’s sensitive places case (Koons) with the full court. If the Third Circuit lands somewhere different from the Second, Fourth, and Ninth Circuits, that split makes Supreme Court review more likely.
And the Court already has a big Second Amendment case this term. On December 2, it hears oral argument in Viramontes v. Cook County (consolidated with Grant v. Higgins) on bans on AR-15s and similar rifles.
A Signal Worth Paying Attention To
Statements like this one don’t change the law. But they do tell litigators what the Court is looking for.
We’ve seen this before. When the Court turned down Maryland’s assault weapons case (Snope) in 2025, Justice Kavanaugh wrote that the Court should address AR-15 bans in the next term or two. Here we are, with an AR-15 case on the December calendar.
We’ll keep following Christian, Koons, and the AR-15 case and post updates here in our Law section as they happen.